Tankless vs. Tank Water Heaters: Which Do I Need?

Tank vs. Tankless Water Heater: Which Is Right for You? | LaVergne's Plumbing & Heating
Water Heater Guide
LaVergne's Plumbing & Heating

Tank vs. Tankless Water Heater

Both provide the hot water your home needs — but they work very differently. Here's a complete, honest comparison to help you decide which option is the right fit for your home and your family.

Everyone Needs Hot Water — But Which System?

It does not matter what type of home a person has, there is something that remains the same — everyone needs a way to heat their water for bathing, cleaning, and cooking. Today, water heaters come in various styles and sizes, but two of the best options include the standard type with a tank and tankless units.

Both these water heater options provide the heated water needed; however, they work differently. Depending on a person's home and their unique needs, one option may be a better fit than the other.

Understanding How They Work

A

Tank-Style Water Heater

Heats & Stores Water 24/7

This unit includes a large container (the tank) that is installed in the home. Its job is to heat and maintain the water and keep it at a constant temperature. The heaters are available in all sizes, starting at just 25 gallons. They can be fueled by electricity, propane, oil, and gas.

The system works by heating the cold water that comes into the home to the desired temperature and stores it until demanded. This system works 24/7, which means there is always hot water available.

🛢️

Large Tank

Starting at 25 gallons. Stored in a utility closet, basement, or easy-to-reach area.

Multiple Fuel Types

Electricity, propane, oil, or gas — several options to match your home's setup.

🔄

Continuous Heating

Heats water around the clock — hot water is always ready when you need it.

📍

Floor Installation

Typically placed in a basement or utility closet. Requires dedicated floor space.

B

Tankless Water Heater

Heats Water On-Demand — Standby When Not in Use

A tankless heater is installed on the wall. These are smaller since they are not designed to store the water inside. Instead, the pipes that supply the water move through the unit, and it is heated on demand.

Usually, these units run on propane; however, some models use electricity. When no water moves through the unit, they are in standby mode, which means they are not using any fuel or heating up the water.

📐

Wall-Mounted

Compact unit mounted on the wall — no floor space required.

♨️

On-Demand Heating

Water is heated only as it flows through the unit — not stored in a tank.

😴

Standby Mode

Uses zero fuel or energy when no water is flowing through the system.

🔥

Propane or Electric

Most models run on propane. Some electric models are also available.

Energy Efficiency

Tank: Runs Continuously

Uses Energy Even When You're Not Home

Since tank-style heaters will run continuously, they are using energy all the time. If someone goes out of town for a few days and does not use any hot water, the tank is still heating the water and using energy.

Some tank-style heaters have also been set to heat water to a higher temperature than what most people really need, which means they use even more energy. While the temperature can be reduced manually, water heaters use a constant energy supply.

Tankless: On-Demand Energy Use

Much Less Energy Overall

A tankless heater only comes on when water moves through it, which means they use much less energy overall. These do not use a constant energy supply, but they require more energy when they are operating.

💡 How Much Water Do You Use?

For homes that use 41 gallons or under of hot water each day, they will use up to 34% less energy with a tankless unit. The savings go down as the number of gallons used each day increases. For example, if a homeowner fills up a huge bathtub each night or uses more water for showers, dishwashers, and washing machines, the traditional tank-style unit may be the better fit.

The Installation Process

🔧

Tank: Quick & Straightforward

Position, Connect Fuel & Water — Done

Of the two models, the tank-style unit is much easier to install. It takes just a few minutes to put the heater in the proper position and connect the fuel and water supply. Since the tank is typically found in a utility closet, basement, or another easy-to-reach area, the installation is not considered difficult or invasive.

🔧

Tankless: More Involved

Inside the Walls — Pipes Must Be Spliced

A tankless heater has a much more complicated installation process. It is installed inside the walls; the pipes must be spliced and then connected on both sides.

⚠️ Installation Steps
  • Find the pipe and determine the best installation location
  • Open the wall to access the plumbing
  • Cut and disconnect the pipes for splicing
  • Install the tankless unit and mount it securely
  • Reconnect the pipes on both sides of the unit
  • Fix the walls — finishing work may be required depending on location

The Costs

$

Purchase & Installation Costs

Tank Is Cheaper Upfront — Tankless Costs More

A tank-style water heater is typically priced for its size. If the home has three to four people living there, a 50-gallon tank is needed, which can cost around $500 for a gas-powered option. A homeowner must also take into account the installation cost.

A tankless unit will usually cost more to install but has similar purchase prices. While the final cost of a standard tank unit may be upwards of $700 with installation, a tankless unit can cost up to $1,500, sometimes more.

🛢️

Tank-Style Total

~$500 unit + installation = ~$700 total. Easier install, lower upfront cost.

📐

Tankless Total

Similar unit price, but installation is more involved = up to $1,500+.

💡
Long-Term Value: While a tankless unit costs more upfront, the energy savings over its longer lifespan (20–30 years vs. 10–12 years) can more than make up the difference. Consider total cost of ownership, not just the purchase price.

Durability & Lifespan

Tank: 10–12 Years

Corrosion & Sediment Wear It Down

The standard, tank-style unit will last for around 10 to 12 years. The main reason it does not last as long is because of poor water and sediment. As time passes, corrosion caused by mineral buildup and constant water wears away the valves and the tank's base.

With regular draining and cleaning the sediment at the bottom of the tank, it can help prolong the unit's lifespan.

Tankless: 20–30 Years

No Standing Water = Less Corrosion

A tankless unit lasts, on average, 20 to 30 years when it is properly maintained. Since they are not continually exposed to standing water, the tank will not corrode or experience the same sediment issues at the base that standard tanks do.

However, more mineral issues may arise. Hard water can cause severe problems for any tankless unit, which means that proper maintenance is essential.

⚠️ Hard Water Warning

Hard water can cause severe problems for tankless units. Mineral buildup can reduce efficiency and damage components over time. If your home has hard water, discuss water softening options or a maintenance schedule with your plumber to protect your investment.

Hot Water Limits

🚿

Tank: Limited by Tank Size

Once It's Empty, You Wait

A massive problem with a standard storage-style tank is that it will heat and then maintain the water inside, and once the water is used, a person must wait for it to fully refill and reheat the new water before more is available.

If a house has a 50-gallon heater and people in the house take several showers back-to-back, they will have to wait for the unit to refill and reheat before having more hot water. The best option for solving this is purchasing a bigger tank than what is usually used in one day.

🚿

Tankless: Unlimited Hot Water

As Long as Water Enters, It's Heated

A tankless unit will not run out of water because it will heat the water as it enters the system. As long as there is freshwater entering the system, the homeowner will have an ongoing hot water source.

Complete Comparison

Feature Tank-Style Tankless ★
How It Works Heats & stores water 24/7 Heats on-demand only
Energy Use Continuous — even when away On-demand — standby mode
Efficiency (≤41 gal/day) Baseline Up to 34% less energy
Installation Quick & straightforward Complex — wall opening, pipe splicing
Upfront Cost ~$700 with install Up to $1,500+
Lifespan 10–12 years 20–30 years
Hot Water Supply Limited by tank size Unlimited (within flow rate)
Size / Footprint Large — requires floor space Compact — wall-mounted
Corrosion Risk High — standing water Low — no standing water
Best For High daily water usage homes Moderate usage, long-term savings
Quick Reference

Tank vs. Tankless — At a Glance

Energy — Tank runs 24/7. Tankless only uses energy on-demand. Up to 34% savings for ≤41 gal/day.
🔧
Installation — Tank is quick and easy. Tankless requires wall opening, pipe splicing, and finishing work.
💰
Cost — Tank ~$700 total. Tankless up to $1,500+. But tankless pays back over its longer lifespan.
Durability — Tank lasts 10–12 years. Tankless lasts 20–30 years with proper maintenance.
🚿
Hot water — Tank is limited by size. Tankless provides unlimited hot water within its flow rate.
The right choice depends on your home. Daily water usage, budget, and long-term plans all factor in. Contact LaVergne's to discuss which unit is right for you.
Which One Is Right for Your Home?

Tank or Tankless? Let's Find Out.

Deciding which water heater is right for you can be complicated. LaVergne's Plumbing & Heating can review your home's needs, water usage, and budget to recommend the best option — and install it professionally. Contact us today to schedule your next service.

Scroll to Top